Articles

Protecting Inheritances from the Consequences of Marriages Concluded in Community of Property.

Do you wish to bequeath an inheritance to your beneficiaries but are concerned that they are married under the community of property regime? Are you seeking ways to ensure that the assets you bequeath are safeguarded from potential claims by their spouses and/or creditors?

We have advised numerous clients on strategies to protect their intended inheritances from marital claims arising from the dissolution of marriages concluded in community of property, and from creditors. This article explores the implications of the community of property regime and how to structure an inheritance to minimise the aforementioned risks.


Understanding the Community of Property Regime

It is essential to understand the nature and implications of this marital regime. When a couple is married in community of property, in terms of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, read with the South African common law, all the assets and liabilities of both spouses are combined into a joint estate. One of the implications is that they share equal responsibility for debts incurred by either party. This principle applies mutatis mutandis to customary marriages, which are presumed to be in community of property under Section 7(2) of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act, 1998.


Can a Will Protect an Inheritance from forming part of the Joint Estate?

Under the community of property regime, inheritances and donations generally become part of the joint estate. However, they can be excluded if the testator or donor explicitly states in the will or donation agreement that the inheritance or donation should remain the separate property of the beneficiary.

The Courts have emphasised that it is the responsibility of the testator or donor to clearly exclude the inheritance from the joint estate. In Rabalao v Mogoje (3113/2019) [2020] ZALMPPHC 101 (10 December 2020), Judge Naudé J stated:

“If the spouses, the testator, or the donor did not pertinently exclude the inheritance or donation from the consequences of the recipient’s in community of property estate, then it is not automatically excluded from such joint estate.“

Therefore, under a marriage in community of property, a beneficiary’s inheritance forms part of the joint estate and is subject to division. To preserve the inheritance as separate property, the testator must incorporate an express testamentary exclusion clause in the will.


Does a Testamentary Exclusion Clause Protect an Inheritance bequeathed to a spouse married in community of property from Creditors?

While a testamentary exclusion clause can protect an inheritance from a beneficiary’s spouse, it does not necessarily shield the inheritance from creditors. The joint estate remains liable for debts incurred by either spouse, and in cases of sequestration, the inherited assets may be used to satisfy creditors’ claims.

In Badenhorst v Bekker NO 1994 (2) SA 155 (N), a spouse who was married in community of property was sequestrated in 1985 after inheriting assets under a will that contained a testamentary exclusion clause. The trustees of the insolvent estate laid a claim to the inherited assets to pay creditors. The spouse brought a Court Application, seeking an order declaring that the inherited assets do not form part of the joint estate. The Court dismissed the Application and ruled that a testator cannot provide a bequest that is exempt from execution by creditors, therefore, inherited assets formed part of the insolvent estate, and could be used to settle debts with creditors.

Similarly, in Du Plessis and Others v Pienaar NO and Others (514/2001) [2002] ZASCA 163, the Supreme Court of Appeal held that sequestration of a joint estate renders both spouses insolvent debtors under the Insolvency Act 24 of 1936. Consequently, creditors can claim both spouses’ undivided interests in the joint estate, including separately owned assets, to satisfy outstanding debts.


Conclusion

A testamentary exclusion clause in a will can protect an inheritance from a beneficiary’s spouse but does not provide absolute protection from creditors of the joint estate.

If asset protection is a primary concern, alternative legal structures such as family trusts and attorney trust accounts may be advisable to provide greater security.

Consulting a legal professional is crucial to ensuring that an inheritance bequeathed to a spouse married in community is structured effectively to align with the wishes of the testator. For a consultation with one of our attorneys, please do not hesitate to contact our offices.


Article written by Ntombizanele P. Motsuenyane

Scroll to Top